Breyers

Per-product safety scores across 84 indexed Breyers items — combining FDA SAFFA status, CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings, and state-level ingredient bans.

Verify with FDA SAFFA →
Avg Safety Score
87.7
Products
84
Flagged Products
33.3%
Dye Pledge
No
Breyers brand profile vs portfolio averages
Signal Breyers Notes
Avg safety score 87.7/100 Mid-range
Products tracked 84 OpenFoodFacts US index
Flagged ingredients 33.3% FDA SAFFA + CSPI flag overlap
Public dye pledge No Per FDA Dye Tracker disclosures

What the Data Says About

Breyers: 84 products tracked, avg safety score 87.7/100, 33.3% of catalog has at least one flagged ingredient. Dye pledge: No.

Score 85-95 reflects mostly-safe profile with some flagged ingredients in specific SKUs. Scoring methodology + dye-pledge context →

Safety scores weigh each product's ingredient list against FDA additive guidance and Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) concern ratings, then average across the brand's tracked catalog. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban — it marks an additive that one of these authorities lists for caution, such as a synthetic dye, a nitrite preservative, or a high-intensity sweetener. Scores shift as brands reformulate and as the underlying datasets refresh, so a brand-level average is a starting point, not a verdict — open the individual product pages for the detail behind any number.

Products by

Sorted by concern level (most flagged first)

Caramel and chocolate light ice cream, caramel and chocolate
Desserts
9 flagged 0/100
M&M Minis Caramel Fudge
Snacks
6 flagged 0/100
Breyersreese'schocolatereese'sminipieces in icecream
Desserts
5 flagged 0/100
Rainbow Sprinkles
Baking-decorations
4 flagged 0/100
Chocolate Sprinkles
4 flagged 0/100
Carb Smart Fudge Bars
Desserts
3 flagged 65/100
Caramel Swirl Bars
3 flagged 65/100
Vanilla Chocolate Strawberry
Desserts
3 flagged 65/100
Carb Smart Vanilla
Desserts
3 flagged 65/100
Breyers no sugar added vanilla chocolate strawberry
2 flagged 70/100
Carb smart peanut butter frozen dairy dessert
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Carb smart mint fudge cookie ice cream
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Chocolate Peanut Butter
2 flagged 70/100
Carb Smart Rocky Road
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Frozen dairy dessert
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Chocolate Frozen Dairy Dessert
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Carb Smart Almond Bars
Desserts
2 flagged 70/100
Breyers Reeses pt
Desserts
2 flagged 80/100
Non-Dairy Vanilla Made with Oat Milk
Desserts
2 flagged 90/100
Breyers Snack Cups, Chocolate
Desserts
2 flagged 90/100
Brownie a la Mode
1 flagged 85/100
Frozen S'mores Dessert Bars
1 flagged 95/100
Breyers, ice cream sauce, hot fudge
Condiments
1 flagged 95/100
Frozen dairy dessert
Desserts
1 flagged 95/100
Frozen Dairy Dessert
1 flagged 95/100
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Desserts
1 flagged 95/100
Non-Dairy Chocolate
100/100
Frozen Almond Milk Dessert
Desserts
100/100
Breyers, real fruit topping, strawberry
Baking-decorations
100/100
Cherry Topping
Baking-decorations
100/100
Breyers, real fruit mixed berry topping, mixed berry
Baking-decorations
100/100
S'mores Ice Cream
Snacks
100/100
Oreo Cookies & Cream Frozen Dairy Dessert
Desserts
100/100
Oreo cookies & cream light ice cream
Desserts
100/100
Brownie cheesecake layered frozen dairy dessert
Desserts
100/100
Cinnabon cinnamon roll flavor with other natural flavor
Desserts
100/100
Non-Dairy Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Desserts
100/100
MINT Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
100/100
Reeses ice cream cups
100/100
Vanilla Carb Smart
100/100
Chocolate chocolate chip
100/100
Carb smart mint chocolate chip
100/100
Carb Smart Coffee Cookie Crunch
100/100
Very Berry Cobbler
100/100
Mango Ice cream
100/100
Dulce de leche
100/100
Pistachio Almond
100/100
Star Spangled Scoops
100/100
Strawberry Shortcake Frozen Dairy Dessert
100/100
Carb Smart Strawberry Bars
100/100
All Ingredients
Browse ingredient database
All Brands
Compare brands by safety
Safety Rankings
Top-rated products

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Breyers food safe? ▼

Breyers has an average safety score of 88/100 across 84 tracked products. 33.3% of products contain flagged ingredients.

How many Breyers products are tracked? ▼

Our database tracks 84 Breyers products, with safety scores based on ingredient analysis from FDA and CSPI data.

Does Breyers use artificial dyes? ▼

Breyers has not publicly committed to removing artificial dyes. Check individual product pages for specific dye ingredients.

Learn More

►
Safest Brands Ranked
Data-driven brand safety rankings
 ►
Reading Food Labels
How to decode ingredient lists

Sources & related

Brand safety rankings
How Breyers compares with other brands.
CSPI Chemical Cuisine
Additive safety ratings behind the score.
Brand scores aggregate ingredient-level FDA SAFFA + CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings across Open Food Facts product data. See our methodology. Retrieved and formatted by PlainFoodSafe Editorial.

Disclaimer: Informational purposes only; not professional advice. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban. Consult a qualified professional before making decisions based on this data.