Smucker's

Per-product safety scores across 176 indexed Smucker's items — combining FDA SAFFA status, CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings, and state-level ingredient bans.

Verify with FDA SAFFA →
Avg Safety Score
94.3
Products
176
Flagged Products
11.9%
Dye Pledge
No
Smucker's brand profile vs portfolio averages
Signal Smucker's Notes
Avg safety score 94.3/100 Above-average
Products tracked 176 OpenFoodFacts US index
Flagged ingredients 11.9% FDA SAFFA + CSPI flag overlap
Public dye pledge No Per FDA Dye Tracker disclosures

What the Data Says About

Smucker's: 176 products tracked, avg safety score 94.3/100, 11.9% of catalog has at least one flagged ingredient. Dye pledge: No.

Score 85-95 reflects mostly-safe profile with some flagged ingredients in specific SKUs. Scoring methodology + dye-pledge context →

Safety scores weigh each product's ingredient list against FDA additive guidance and Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) concern ratings, then average across the brand's tracked catalog. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban — it marks an additive that one of these authorities lists for caution, such as a synthetic dye, a nitrite preservative, or a high-intensity sweetener. Scores shift as brands reformulate and as the underlying datasets refresh, so a brand-level average is a starting point, not a verdict — open the individual product pages for the detail behind any number.

Products by

Sorted by concern level (most flagged first)

Funfetti Vanilla Cake
Cooking helpers
5 flagged 0/100
Magic Shell Cupcake
Cooking helpers
4 flagged 0/100
Magic Shell Rainbow Sherbet
Cooking helpers
4 flagged 0/100
Unicorn Magic Shell
Cooking helpers
3 flagged 25/100
Peach Preserves
Plant-based foods and beverages
3 flagged 35/100
Magic shell caramel flavored topping
Desserts
3 flagged 35/100
Sugar Free Concord Grape Jam
3 flagged 35/100
Caramel flavored topping
Caramel-flavored-topping
3 flagged 45/100
Sugar Free Breakfast Syrup
Beverages and beverages preparations
3 flagged 65/100
Butterscotch flavored topping
2 flagged 50/100
Seedless Strawberry Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
2 flagged 60/100
Strawberry Flavored Dessert Topping, Strawberry
Cooking helpers
2 flagged 70/100
Pineapple spoonable ice cream topping
Cooking helpers
1 flagged 75/100
Strawberry flavored topping
Strawberry-topping
1 flagged 75/100
Smucker'S, Magic Shell, Flavored Topping, Pink Lemonade, Pink Lemonade
Cooking helpers
1 flagged 75/100
Hot Milk Chocolate
Cooking helpers
1 flagged 85/100
Blackberry Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
1 flagged 85/100
Sugar Free Strawberry Preserves
Plant-based foods and beverages
1 flagged 85/100
Milk Chocolate Topping
Cooking helpers
1 flagged 85/100
Dark Chocolate Topping, Dark Chocolate
Cooking helpers
1 flagged 95/100
Natural creamy peanut butter
100/100
Low Sugar Concord Grape Reduced Sugar Jelly
100/100
Cider apple butter
100/100
Pecans in syrup topping
100/100
Syrup Walnuts
Cooking helpers
100/100
Spiced Apple Butter
Condiments
100/100
Chocolate fudge topping
Chocolate-fudge
100/100
Hot fudge toppings
100/100
Concord Grape Jam, Concord Grape
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Pineapple Preserves, Pineapple
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Red Raspberry Jam
100/100
Strawberry preserves
100/100
Concord Grape Jelly
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Strawberry Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Sugar free strawberry topping
100/100
Concord Grape Jelly
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Peach Preserves
100/100
Red Raspberry Preserves
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Blackberry Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Strawberry Preserves
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Blackberry Jelly, Blackberry
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Concord Grape Jelly
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Boysenberry jam
100/100
Seedless red raspberry jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Strawberry Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Smucker'S, Apricot-Pineapple Preserves
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Concord Grape Jam
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Low Sugar Strawberry Preserves
100/100
Low Sugar Sweetener, Red Raspberry
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
Natural Peanut Butter
Plant-based foods and beverages
100/100
All Ingredients
Browse ingredient database
All Brands
Compare brands by safety
Safety Rankings
Top-rated products

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Smucker's food safe? ▼

Smucker's has an average safety score of 94/100 across 176 tracked products. 11.9% of products contain flagged ingredients.

How many Smucker's products are tracked? ▼

Our database tracks 176 Smucker's products, with safety scores based on ingredient analysis from FDA and CSPI data.

Does Smucker's use artificial dyes? ▼

Smucker's has not publicly committed to removing artificial dyes. Check individual product pages for specific dye ingredients.

Learn More

►
Safest Brands Ranked
Data-driven brand safety rankings
 ►
Reading Food Labels
How to decode ingredient lists

Sources & related

Brand safety rankings
How Smucker's compares with other brands.
CSPI Chemical Cuisine
Additive safety ratings behind the score.
Brand scores aggregate ingredient-level FDA SAFFA + CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings across Open Food Facts product data. See our methodology. Retrieved and formatted by PlainFoodSafe Editorial.

Disclaimer: Informational purposes only; not professional advice. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban. Consult a qualified professional before making decisions based on this data.