Overjoyed

Per-product safety scores across 48 indexed Overjoyed items — combining FDA SAFFA status, CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings, and state-level ingredient bans.

Avg Safety Score
96.9
Products
48
Flagged Products
6.3%
Dye Pledge
No
Overjoyed brand profile vs portfolio averages
Signal Overjoyed Notes
Avg safety score 96.9/100 Above-average
Products tracked 48 OpenFoodFacts US index
Flagged ingredients 6.3% FDA SAFFA + CSPI flag overlap
Public dye pledge No Per FDA Dye Tracker disclosures

What the Data Says About

Overjoyed: 48 products tracked, avg safety score 96.9/100, 6.3% of catalog has at least one flagged ingredient. Dye pledge: No.

Score ≥95 places Overjoyed in the top-decile safety tier — ingredient profiles dominated by FDA/CSPI low-concern items. Scoring methodology + dye-pledge context →

Safety scores weigh each product's ingredient list against FDA additive guidance and Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI) concern ratings, then average across the brand's tracked catalog. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban — it marks an additive that one of these authorities lists for caution, such as a synthetic dye, a nitrite preservative, or a high-intensity sweetener. Scores shift as brands reformulate and as the underlying datasets refresh, so a brand-level average is a starting point, not a verdict — open the individual product pages for the detail behind any number.

Products by

Sorted by concern level (most flagged first)

Birthday Cake Trail Mix
3 flagged 25/100
Mint cookies and crème indulgent trail mix
Snacks
3 flagged 35/100
Pumpkin spice mini cupcakes
Snacks
2 flagged 90/100
Harvest variety, cheesecake
100/100
Banana Cream Pie
100/100
Coconut Cream Pie
100/100
Chocolate chips
Snacks
100/100
Rainbow Sprinkles
100/100
Peppermint Cocoa Indulgent Trail Mix
100/100
Pumpkin Spice Yogurt Covered Pretzels
100/100
Sour Vampire Teeth Gummies
100/100
Skull Gummies
100/100
Harvest Spice Trail Mix
100/100
Maple Leaf Crème Cookies
100/100
Mini Cupcake Grocery Bakery
100/100
Unicorn Cupcakes
100/100
Pumpkin Spice Sandwich Cookies
100/100
Holiday Tree-Shaped Pretzels With Sprinkles
100/100
Peppermint Yogurt Covered Pretzels
100/100
Overjoyed Cheesecake
100/100
Extreme! Moose Tracks Indulgent Trail Mix
100/100
Peanut Butter Chocolate Overload Trail Mix
100/100
Turtle Sundae Trail Mix
100/100
Carrot Cake Sandwich Cookies
100/100
Vanilla Mini Cupcakes
100/100
Chocolate Cupcake, Mini
100/100
Lemon White Chocolate Waffle Cones
100/100
Lemon Dipped Cookies
100/100
Lemon Flavored Yogurt Pretzels
100/100
Lemon Coated Blueberries
100/100
Birthday Cake Soft Baked Cookies
Snacks
100/100
Limited Edition Frosted Sugar Cookies
100/100
Frosted Pumpkin Pie Bites
100/100
S’mores Mini Cupcake
100/100
S’mores Frosted Cookies
100/100
Cinnamon Churro-inspired Indulgent Trail Mix
100/100
Pumpkin Spice Tea Cookie
100/100
S'mores Flavored Baking Chips
100/100
Salted Caramel Baking Chips
100/100
Crème Brǔlée Frozen Dessert
100/100
Fudge Covered Cookies With Peppermint Pieces
100/100
Hazelnut wafer rolls
Snacks
100/100
Overjoyed Cranberry Walnut Cookies
100/100
Cookies And Crème Ice Cream Cake
100/100
Hot Chocolate Cupcake
100/100
Mini cupcakes
100/100

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Overjoyed food safe?

Overjoyed has an average safety score of 97/100 across 48 tracked products. 6.3% of products contain flagged ingredients.

How many Overjoyed products are tracked?

Our database tracks 48 Overjoyed products, with safety scores based on ingredient analysis from FDA and CSPI data.

Does Overjoyed use artificial dyes?

Overjoyed has not publicly committed to removing artificial dyes. Check individual product pages for specific dye ingredients.

Brand scores aggregate ingredient-level FDA SAFFA + CSPI Chemical Cuisine ratings across Open Food Facts product data. See our methodology. Retrieved and formatted by PlainFoodSafe Editorial.

Disclaimer: Informational purposes only; not professional advice. A flagged ingredient is not a recall or a ban. Consult a qualified professional before making decisions based on this data.